B5 Argument Chart

Basic Argument
Evidence	Rule	Conclusion = Claim
There is a glass in Arthur's hand. Arthur's feet are pointing up the stairs. He is lying on his back. Arthur's clothing is not disheveled. (messed up) The carpet on the stairs is  not messed up. The stove is on.	As a rule, when someone falls downstairs with a glass, the glass would break. As a rule, when someone falls, they drop whatever they're holding and try to catch themselves. As a rule, when a person is coming down the stairs and trips, he or she would either fall forward and land facedown, or fall backward onto the stairs (probably with their feet still on the stairs). When people fall, they try to catch themselves on anything they can grab. Candle flames would go out because of the air movement.	Queenie is lying. Queenie is lying.