Checklist for Author Letters
adapted from teaching materials at http://www.lettersaboutliterature.org/lesson_plans
See the teacher scoring rubric at http://cavemanenglish.pbworks.com/Rubric-for-Letter-to-an-Author
I. . Content
- Purpose: Does the letter address the essay's theme -- describing how a work of literature somehow changed the reader's view of the world or self?
- Audience: Does the reader demonstrate a knowledge of his or her audience? In other words, is the writer addressing the author and not the teacher or others?
- Supporting Details: Does the letter provide explanations or examples, anecdotes, or other specific details to support the reader's point of view?
- Does the reader dialogue wit the author rather than summarizing the book's plot or analyzing literary elements within the book?
- Does the reader correspond with the author rather than compliment?
- Is vocabulary smooth and natural rather than "tongue-tied" or showy?
III. Organization and Grammatical Correctness
- Does the reader present ideas in a logical, organized manner without unnecessary repetition?
- What organizational strategy (internal text structure) does the writer use?
- chronological order if relating a story
- cause-and-effect
- compare/contrast
- steps in a process
- other: _____________________________________
- Does the essay have bookends -- an introduction or lead paragraph that hooks the reader plus a concluding paragraph that may or may not mirror the opening paragraph?
- Has the reader proofread the letter for errors of spelling, capitalization, and punctuation?